THE ESSENTIALS IN 30 SECONDS

  • In 2025, 24% of people selected for officer-initiated facial recognition checks by South Wales Police were from ethnic minorities, against about 7% of the local population and 11% of arrests.
  • Officers scanned 257 adults and 14 children using a smartphone app that runs NEC's NeoFace algorithm against custody images and other databases.
  • The force says the figures raise concerns about disproportionality and that it is reviewing its use of the tool, which it describes as small-scale and at an early stage.

People from ethnic minority backgrounds made up nearly a quarter of those South Wales Police chose to check with its handheld facial recognition tool in 2025, according to internal force figures. The data was obtained by the campaign group Big Brother Watch under the Freedom of Information Act and first reported by The Guardian on November 15.

What the figures show

The tool, known as operator-initiated facial recognition, lets an officer photograph someone's face with a smartphone and search it with NEC's NeoFace algorithm against custody images and other face databases. It is distinct from the live camera systems the force has also used. According to the reports, officers ran checks on 257 adults and 14 children in 2025, two of them under 10.

Ethnic minority people accounted for 24% of those selected, while they make up about 7% of the population the force serves and 11% of people arrested in its area. The Guardian's headline describes this as roughly four times the expected rate; the reports do not set out exactly how that ratio was calculated.

More than half of the scans concerned people suspected of an offence, unlawfully at large or in breach of bail. Others involved people thought to pose a risk of harm, missing persons, or the identification of someone who had died, which happened roughly once a fortnight. Where a match was found, 48% of cases led to an arrest and about a third to no further action.

The police response and criticism

South Wales Police said the figures raise concerns about disproportionality and that it will review its approach with independent advisory groups and external scrutiny panels. It also stressed that use of the tool remains small, is at an early stage, and that each use depends on the situation officers face and is subject to supervisory oversight.

Jake Hurfurt of Big Brother Watch called the disparity alarming. Aliya Mohammed, chief executive of Cardiff-based Race Equality First, warned that existing biases in who gets stopped could be amplified by the technology.

Wider context

The figures show who officers chose to scan, not whether the algorithm itself performs differently across groups, a separate question the reports do not address. Similar tools are being trialled by the Metropolitan Police and have been tested in Liverpool, while the Home Office has announced a new oversight body for police facial recognition, according to the Wales Times.